This essay focuses on three works namely: the article “Size 6: The Western Women’s Harem” by Fatema Mernissi, the essay “How It Feels To Be Colored Me” by Zora Hurston, and the essay “On Seeing England for the First Time” by Jamaica Kincaid. The three texts are inexorably written on rhetorical analysis of cultures, beliefs, and other scattered fragments of the same. The works focus on rhetorical strategic analysis in the lives of three different cultures and traditions.
The preliminary thesis in the texts is to show contradicting differences between the three of them in relation to the cultural differences, ethical perspectives, and identity ideas.
Summary of Main Points
“How It Feels to Be Colored Me” by Zola Hurston, is an essay that explores the discovery of self-pride and identity. The author uses imagery, figurative language, and colorful diction to describe the conventions of the same. Hurston explains that she does not waste time in thinking that she is tragically colored but uses the time to sharpen her self-pride. In this particular work, the author challenges a mindset held by many colored people. She is proud of being black and does not allow black ghosts to haunt her. Similarly, the article “Size 6: The Western Women’s Harem” by Fatema Mernissi is a mesmerizing work that discusses and elaborates a rich heritage, unique experiences, unexpected encroachments, and peculiarities faced by a woman from harem. In this article, the author includes attitudes, conditions, and discoveries from different women all over the world and explains that she has been taught to live under the veil but is determined to use her wings and view beyond the veil. In the essay “On Seeing England for the First Time” by Jamaica Kincaid, the author describes in detail a patriotic English history and traditions (Hurston, 2007). The author goes deeper into prejudice, colonialism, and racism in England.
Analysis on the Imposed Values
In the essay, “On Seeing England for the First Time”, the author brings out slavery in many forms. She also shows her distasteful attitude and rebellion towards England for imposing values that are based on racism, prejudice, and colonialism. The author displays England as a very beautiful jewel, which is worn by only special persons. This simply means that she uses a unique technique to highlight her feelings. She also makes use of a sarcastic voice by masking excoriation with praise of England. This helps to demonstrate her real attitude towards England. At the end of the essay, Kincaid tries to invoke sympathy from the reader by showing an imperialistic agenda of the same. In this way, she opens up the consequences of slavery to the reader. By employing this rhetorical strategy, the author succeeds in expressing her personal views about England to the reader and the world at large.
In the essay “How It Feels to Be Colored Me”, the author describes her image and other people’s perspective on the color, which was imposed upon her from her early childhood. She explains that she has learnt to accept herself as she is and that she did not pay much attention on how other people viewed her. This simply means that the author uses a cultural analysis to identify and evaluate the markers imposed by other people’s perception on whom she was. The author also explains that she does not accept an imposed hierarchy on the same. In other words, she tries to explain that imposed values can influence certain standards upon the black women and make them feel powerless and less privileged (Mernissi, 2001). On the other hand, in the article “Size 6: The Western Women’s Harem” by Mernissi, the author talks about suppressed and imposed values on religious, cultural, sexual desires, shame, and sex object concept on women. She explains that there are many violent restrictions that are dictated on Muslim women. This simply means that the values tied on western women only paralyze their ability to access education, compete for power, and access professional opportunities. The imposed values affect the sense of effectiveness and the self-esteem of these women. However, the big question is: Should women’s emotions, traits, and anxieties be taken into consideration while weighing the game rules in the western world?
Analysis of the Cultural Outsiderness
In the article “Size 6: The western Women’s Harem”, the author explains that she realized she had faced a cultural gap when tried to buy a skirt in America and that her human rights had been violated. The author also explains that, at this instance, she realized that there were so many cultural practices, which challenged the western social order or were outside the western social order. This simply means that the western world encourages cultural development but does not consider intellectual development outside the cultural system. Similarly, in the essay “How It Feels to Be Colored Me” the cultural bias is based on color. This simply means that color is an outside cultural marker in this work. She explains how this cultural bias discriminates and brings great sorrow to the black culture, and in order to survive with the outside cultures, the black people have to be proud of who they are. By analogy, in the essay “On Seeing England for the First Time the author talks about cultural traditions, such as prejudice and racism. These cultures, according to author only help to discriminate and favor special groups of persons in England.
Analysis of Cultural Relativism
Cultural relativism simply means seeing things from a different point of view or perspective. This type of relativism requires tolerance policies. This simply means that other people’s perspective is a very important characteristic on the same. The author of the essay “On Seeing England for the First Time” tries to represent the notion that every culture needs to be understood and analyzed. This is because cultural relativism has great effects on trauma analysis. In the essay, “How It Feels to Be Colored Me”, the author admits that her feelings tend to concede with the cultural relativism (Atwan, 1992). This helps to look into the cultural prescription contents in order to explore perspectives on self-pride and identify. Similarly, in the article, “The Western Women’s Harem”, the problems faced by the western women and the legal issues form the cultural relativism. This is because while women from the South suffer from these problems, the ones from the North have solutions to them.
Analysis of Self-awareness & Self-realization
In the article “Size 6: The Western Women’s Harem”, the author tries to create a self-realization and self-awareness of the fact that western women are blinded by their veils. The self-realization concept simply means the ultimate goal taken by a person in order to obtain freedom, complete independence, and permanent happiness. Similarly, in the essay “How It Feels to Be Colored Me”, the author is unfulfilled and angry over the cultural differences and tries to attain self-realization and self-awareness by creating her own self-image. In the essay “On Seeing England for the First Time”, the author explains the importance of self-education in the development of self-awareness and self-realization.
Analysis of Confinement vs. Freedom
According to Fatima Mernissi, she was bound like a slave and was not allowed freedom. This simply means that they were confined to limited time and space. According to Hurston, African American women suffer from confinement. The author, however, touches on freedom aspects from the historic times. Similarly, Kincaid suggests in her essay that confinement is an outward limit and that only intellectual freedom can clear all hesitation in a spectral existence.
Analysis of Protest vs. Resistance
Kincaid assumes that protest is a choice that could be powerless and only lead to rejection, dejection, depression, and discouragements. On the other hand, she states that resistance is powerful because it mobilizes and empowers the candidate. Alternatively, Hurston suggests that black protest and resistance are both powerful weapons. She says that elements of the same have become the center of contemporary achievements in the black community. On the other part, Mernissi asserts that protests and resistance are only a myth in the west. The author also affirms that this is the only way that the western women can spread their wings.
Summary on the Traits, Themes and Other Common Features
The three authors use emotional, anxious, passive, and distinctive personality traits. They also use interpretation and perception themes in order to explore and justify their attributes about deferent issues. The other common features used in the three works are objects, symbols, characters, color, figure, and exceptional qualities (Kincaid, 1985).
The three texts: “How It feels to Be Colored Me”, “Size 6: The Western Women’s Harem”, and “On Seeing England for the First Time” are unique ones based on cultural difference, ethic perspectives, and limitations in the societies or community. The works explore discovery on self-identity, self-pride, realization, discrimination, and cultural differences. All the three writers attribute for freedom from different kinds of confinement.
|Hand of Communication||Values|